THE GOOD: The front-back rocking function is perfectly smooth and the chair back is high. For reference, the height of the back from the cushion to the top listed for the chair (24.25") is a vertical measurement, but the back of the chair is at a slant, so it is actually longer than the listed height. I measured with a measuring tape, and it is closer to 27", which is great for my husband and I because we are both tall (I am 5'9" and my husband is 6'1"). I love the fabric, but I am a person who hates microfiber. The color is a little blue to my eye, and I think it is soft and high quality. Other reviewers mention having trouble staying in the reclined position - this is not an issue at all for us. The foot rest is difficult to put down as others have noted, particularly to get it to lock into place, but this is not something that bothers us and I wouldn't say it is especially more difficult than other recliners I have sat in. My husband thinks the chair comfort is OK, not the best and not the worst. I think it is comfortable. We looked at chairs in person ranging from $500 - $2000 and both my husband and I agree the comfort of this chair competes with those and beats most. This chair is high quality and an excellent value. THE BAD: I was really expecting to give this chair 5 stars, but I have to go with 4 because I am disappointed with the "swivel" function. It's not smooth like I was hoping. It takes a bit of effort to get it to swivel from side to side, and there is sort of a vibration or grinding noise when you swivel. It is not loud, but it is there. Our chair wasn't handled very well in shipping (the box had clearly marked "this side up" labels on the package but arrive on it's side and beat up) so I thought maybe it got damaged, but we flipped the chair over and looked at the mechanism and nothing is bent or out of place. I did rotate the swivel base back and forth repeatedly while it was flipped over, and this seemed to help, so maybe it will become less stiff with time. But bottom line, the swivel is not as smooth as I was hoping, especially compared to the front-back rocking function which is perfectly smooth.