Skip to Main Content
Sign In
Sign In

Best Toasters With Reviews

Top-rated customer favorites with reviews

KitchenAid® 4-Slice Toaster with Manual High-Lift Lever

KitchenAid® 4-Slice Toaster with Manual High-Lift Lever

$94.99

Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

01/17/2019
Another Great KitchenAid Addition to the Home!
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I needed a four slice toaster for my kitchen and after looking at many different models and brands, I ultimately decided on this KitchenAid 4 slice unit. I am glad I did. I purchased the toaster through a popular home improvement store. The item was shipped to me, albeit directly in its KitchenAid packaging. Despite that, it arrived safely, no harm. The toaster is well packaged, secured in styrofoam forms, and wrapped in clear plastic, with a protective static barrier on the unit as well. The chord is long enough to reach an outlet, and the toaster is designed to allow the chord to be tucked underneath the toaster. The toaster has two easy removing crumb trays that are easy to clean. The toaster slots are large enough to accept bagels and Texas Toast which is a thick piece of bread. The browning dials are easily operated. You can toast either one, two, three, or four slices. The levers also move upward to raise the toast/bagel/pastry up so that you do not burn your hands on the heating area. An excellent feature. The fit and finish of the toaster is excellent. I ran it through a couple of cycles at setting 5 to "burn" the toaster in and eliminate any of the new smell that comes from unused elements. The toaster works perfectly. I could not have asked for a nicer toaster. Well built. Great fit and finish. Stylish. It does the job nicely. I rate this item 5*s out of 5. Thank you KitchenAid for offering such a great item. It will be well used.
Hamilton Beach® Brushed Stainless Steel Toaster

Hamilton Beach® Brushed Stainless Steel Toaster

$42.44

Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

09/22/2017
It Just Works
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Hamilton Beach Brushed Stainless Steel Two-Slice Pop-up Toaster Model 22910 From the box: 2 Extra - Wide Slots Easy Cleanup with slide-out crumb tray High-lift toast boost Adjustable browning control Cancel / auto shutoff Bottom hidden cord wrap Initial impression: No bagel switch. The slots are wide enough for bagel halves but, both sides are going to toast. The "Read before use" leaflet, has a bullet point in the first column: "Do not use with rice cakes, fried foods, frozen prepared foods, or nonbread items." While number 5, in the second column under the, "How to toast," heading says: "Frozen foods may require an additional toasting cycle." Additionally, in column two under the "Parts and features," heading, item 5 refers to item 5 depicted in the drawing as: 5. Slide-Out Crumb Tray Two points on this. A. Number 5 points to the long side to the left as one faces the end with the bread lifter, and the shade selector. The crumb tray actually slides out the opposite short end. B. Further down the second column, under the, "Cleaning" heading, number 2 says: "2. Place the toaster on its side." "Open the crumb tray and wipe off with clean cloth; then close." Again, the crumb tray slides out the short end opposite of the controls end. My Review: After a few weeks using only it for toasting, I find I appreciate it more than I thought I would. It toasts regular white sandwich bread and Texas toast slices fairly uniformly time after time. It doesn't matter one slice or two at a time. Or, whether single slices are done in either slot. The top of the slice will be more done than the rest of the slice. Heat rises. I did find the outer sides of each slice were a darker shade than the sides to the inside elements. I would have expected it to be the other way around. Since, it characteristically browns the outer sides more than the inner sides, we toasted bagel halves with the cut sides facing the outer elements. This toaster does not have a bagel switch, which my four-slice toaster used to deactivate the heating elements on the non cut sides. My preconceived expectation was that I wouldn't care for bagels from this unit. I was pleasantly surprised to find I prefer them from this two-slice toaster. I expected the bagel half outsides to be toasted crunchy, but they weren't. Although a little firmer, they were still pliable and provide a wonderful warm chewy texture. I found using plain bagels from this toaster for sandwiches provided for a warm chewy bite throughout to the end. Where as, from my four-slice toaster the bagel halves would not be warmed all the way through. We also did cinnamon swirl and maple french toast bagel halves with the same excellent results as the plain bagels. All the bagel halves, so far, have done well at the same setting as for regular white or Texas toast bread slices. Split English muffins require a much higher heat setting. Even then, the cut side, although crisply toasted, doesn't brown much prior to the other side getting too done. The high-lift toast boost, comes in handy for split English muffins. Again, it provides for very uniform results, even if only toasting a single half in either slot. I did notice a propensity for the right slot to launch a muffin half out of the toaster to the right when toasting a single half. Not noticed from the left slot, so we do single English muffin halves there. Unfortunately, the wide slices I've tried, of commercially available rye, pumpernickel rye, and swirled rye bread have been too long to go in horizontally. I could only insert them long side vertically, which only provided toasting for approximately three quarters of each slice. Flipping the slices over and toasting them again tends to dry them out. As for toaster pastry (national brand non frozen frosted pop-up tarts), set to the lowest setting they are warmed through without being so hot as to burn your or a child's mouth. The thin tarts are very well centered in the slots. I'm assuming the "Read before use" leaflet's "Do not use with ... frozen prepared foods, ...," refers to frozen pizzas, TV dinners/sides, etc. And, not to frozen prepared items intended for heating in a vertical toaster. Frozen toaster pastry items in example, a national brand combination bacon, sausage, scrambled egg, and cheese variety, takes three cycles set just below number two. Flipping over in the same slot between cycles. Two cycles leave them warm around the edges, but only thawed yet cool in the middle. Three times provides a crisp exterior without burning, and hot filling ingerdients. National branded frozen toaster pastries of the fruit, cream cheese or, cinnamon flavored filling came out nicely with only two cycles set at number two and flipping over back into the same slot prior to the second cycle. Frozen waffles, round ones to both thinner and thicker square ones, came out nicely with two toasting cycles. For the thinner waffles, just below the number two setting for both cycles, and switching slots between cycles. Ensuring the outside right waffle was positioned as the inside left waffle for the second cycle, and vice versa for the left waffle to the right slot. This same positioning worked well for the thicker square waffles but at a slightly lower heat setting. I found it easier on my hand just to switch slots rather than flip them over in the same slot. Less handling time. I noted slices get consistently centered thickness wise, regardless of how thick or thin they are. I assume this contributes greatly to the uniform toasting this toaster provides. I like it, it just works. I would like to know if there is a four-slice version that performs as well? Or, even better, if there is an elongated dual-slice toaster that handles thick and thin slices as well as wider slices of "artisan" type or commercially available wide rye breads?
Dash 2 Slice Long Slot Clear View Toaster

Dash 2 Slice Long Slot Clear View Toaster

$49.99

Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

05/31/2021
SEARCH NO MORE
After my 12 year old Breville finally gave up I went in search of a new toaster. I previewed several prospects and have discovered that buying a new toaster is not at all an easy task. Toasters run the gamete from cheap to super expensive and have several features such as defrost, bagel and reheat, etc. Paying more does not guarantee better performance. Seems most new toaster can not "toast" bread! They either don't toast, burn your bread, toast unevenly, and are not consistent. Ran across the Dash ClearView and found it to have the features I wanted...wide and long slots (1.5 x 10.5) defrost, bagel and reheat functions and a very cool see through window. My Mother had a glass front see through toaster back in the early 80's Don't re,ember the brand and don't see anything like it. Thought I would give the Dash a try and glad I did. My search is over! Toasts perfectly, and is consistant! Ran some tests with white, multigrain bread and English muffins and they were perfect. I like my toast on the lighter side and found the #4 to 4.5 setting to be perfect and the shade matches the illustration in the Dash user manual. DO NOT believe the negative reviews! As far as the "launching" of the toast out of the toaster, I had no such issue. And with the lever not latching and staying down it is "user error" The inner removable glass has a safety switch on the right side of the glass channel if glass is not properly reinserted and switch not engaged, circuit will not complete and toaster will not function. Dash has included an additional instruction sheet describing this. Also, this toaster uses quartz heating tubes, not nichrome ribbon wire. Quartz tubes are more even heating and are more durable than nichrome wire. The only other toaster i have ever seen with quartz tubes was a Krups, and I believe they are no longer made. Bottom line, this toaster does what a toaster should do! Buy it. You will be happy.
ServerT:1.6196260452271