Best Baking Sheets With Reviews

Love trays. I actually don't use them for baking so I can't say how they'd perform in that context. I put them under my cat's food bowls to protect the floor. I don't want to look at something ugly so I bought two of these. Just gorgeous. They do clean up easily with just a damp sponge, so they seem like food would not stick. So now I'm hooked on them and considering getting the matching cookware. For me, not the cats.

I had to buy a gift for 50.00 for Christmas gift exchange and as luck would have it this set pans were marked down for holidays. So was I able to purchase and few other things to go along with. (Still waiting on dough cutter) anyway it was the hit of the Christmas party gift exchange . They were so nice I almost bought something else. Then at dinner party I wanted to steal them from lady who got them. Ha ha but thought might be tacky. They are so so nice! Great silicone handles. I will be buying myself a set!

Had these in half sheet size so when I needed the jelly roll size to fit in our second oven, I knew these Nordic ware were the ones to get. They are great for cookie baking and don’t smell or have any chemicals leak off like my old non stick baking sheets!

Just received the pan. Love the color and smaller size of the sheet pan. However, the package was slightly dented I would guess during shipment since box has damage. The pan is pretty sturdy looking so I was hoping it wasn't dented as well but it was. Still usable and was a reasonable price. I can live with the small dent.

Super excited to use this pan. We are a vegan household so we make a lot of spicy cauliflower bites so the rack allows it to get crispy underneath. Ive waited a long to find a good pan like this, so Im excited to try it however it came with two significantly large dents in it. I am going to try and fix them, I just hope I can get it to lay flat.

You just cant beat Nordic Ware sheet pans. They are high quality, do not flex or bend in the oven and as long as you dont put them in the dishwasher they will retain their finish. I dont ever directly roast most things on them, I always use non stick foil so I dont risk burning food getting stuck to them. Ive had a set for 10 years and they are still great sheet pans with no rust. I bought these because they were on sale and it would bring me up to 4 pans so I can get rid of all my cheap cookie sheets. I highly recommend these!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This pan worked as expected. We did 2 test batches with store bought Pillsbury cookie dough. 1 chocolate chip and 1 sugar. We used the setting for dark pans, 325. Both batches turned out great but a bit flat. I don't think that had much to do with the pan though. It was for the most part nonstick on its own. We didn't use anything in between to test this ability. Cleaning was easy as we stuck this in the dishwasher. So far, we've not had any issues.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love this pan! I have used it for everything from brownies to barbecue chicken and nothing sticks to it. I have a pot and pan set from Gotham Steel as well and it matches them perfect so it all looks like just one big set. This pan is also really easy to clean. Most things just wipe right out. I would recommend this brand to anyone.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love the Granitestone five piece Blue Bakeware set! The set comes with a cookie sheet, a cake pan, a loaf pan, a muffin pan, and a square baking pan. All pieces are solid blue and are non stick. I was a bit worried when I first received the set and read the care instructions. I was worried because it stated not to use non stick cooking spray because it could ruin the pans. I haven't found a bakeware set that if you didn't use the non stick cooking spray wouldn't stick until I got this set. I have used this set so many times and cooked numerous of items in each of the different bakeware pans and have not had an issue with sticking. They are made of a really nice material and seem to be made to last a long time. They have a nice weight to them, which I like, but they are not overly heavy. I have also found they the pan seems to cool down to the touch pretty fast! Which is awesome because I have kiddos running in and out if my kitchen all day. All in all I love this bakeware set and would recommend to anyone looking to purchase a new set!

Absolutely LOVE Circulon products! This baking sheet and rack is really nice. Tonight we used this to bake a meatloaf on. Turned out perfectly!! Having the rack allows any grease to drop down to the pan. Clean up was a breeze!! We used a sponge with Dawn & hot water for cleaning and it truly took little effort. This chocolate color is so pretty. Highly recommend!!

These cookie sheets are by far THE BEST I have used! Thank you, Erika, and her epic customer service. I was using Rachael Ray cookie sheets because all the reviews stated that they did not buckle with use. Ummm, wrong. Erika recommended these cookie sheets (she needs a raise, vacation, SOMETHING). They make everything you bake taste so fresh and perfectly baked. How is that possible? Say bye being jumpy in the kitchen from buckling cookie sheets. Just, WOW!

These are amazing to use in my new counter top oven. They fit perfectly. At first I thought they wouldnt fit because they are small but they fit amazing in my ToasterAir Fryer Oven.

This product deserves 5 stars. I docked it because it simply does not provide quite the ease of use I want for one task--oven baking bacon. The baking part if fine but the cleanup is messier than simply relying on aluminum foil in any baking or roasting pan. Of course, if you save bacon fat or view lining a pan with aluminum foil as wasteful, this could be the product for your bacon in the morning.

I’ve been using the Anolon 3-Piece Cooking Sheet Set for a few weeks now, and I couldn’t be more impressed. From the moment I unpacked them, I could tell these were high-quality baking sheets. The heavy-duty construction gives them a solid, durable feel, and they hasn’t warped in the oven. The nonstick coating is truly nonstick. Cookies, roasted veggies, and even sticky glazes slide right off. I also love the three different sizes included in the set — it gives you flexibility depending on what you’re making, whether it’s a small batch of cookies or a full meal. They nest easily for storage and look sleek and professional. Overall, I highly recommend the Anolon cooking sheet set to anyone who loves baking or roasting. It’s a great investment in quality kitchenware that delivers excellent results every time.

These cookie sheets are terrific. I didn't buy them to make cookies. I am not a baker. I was tired of my heavy pans for making baking fish and broiling steak or anything that needed to be cooked flat. I made salmon in the small sheet at 350 deg. and it was great and came out perfect. I do believe I read on the site about these pans that the temperature needs to be under 400 deg. I do have to say something about the pieces on the end. They do get hot and you need to use a pot holder and they stay hot for a little while. Other than that, I love them. I am sure that they will be great with cookies.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I needed new baking sheets and wanted commercial grade aluminum steel. I am so glad I found not only professional grade aluminum baking sheets but with the added easy to grip handles. The handles are genius! I have burned my hands so many times getting cookies and other items from the oven. This handle, which is generous in size for small to large hands, must be used with a hot mitt. I have squashed my hands in cookies too many times which trying to grip the edge of the sheet to remove from the oven. I have tried several different types of cookies and all bake evenly on the sheets. The scratch resistant is appreciated. The fact you get a cooking and baking rack included is amazing. I have used the rack for cooling coolies but also as a rack to cook french fries. Excellent product and value.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This quarter sheet is the nicest baking sheet I've ever owned. I've bought just about every brand and size. Baking sheets tend to get rusted and burned quickly and have been something I don't usually spend much money on because of. This sheet is the perfect size for everyday use in my single-person household. The sheet itself is super thick and works for every single thing I need to throw in the oven. I have become more sensible about what I am putting into landfills and with that have invested in silicone baking sheets among other earth-friendly supplies. This pan fits a baking sheet with some overlap. It's great for meat, veggies, or baking. With foil, I would also feel perfectly comfortable broiling with this pan. It washes up very well in the dishwasher and fits nicely in my cabinets. All-Clad products are slowly taking over most areas of my kitchen and are consistently at the top of their class. An all-around perfect sheet for 1-2 people households or small snacks in bigger households.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The AllClad Pro-Release Cookie Sheet is a wonderful baking sheet. I love how easily cookies, biscuits, scones, you name it, come off. Plus, sweets cook evenly and I love the lip on it. I seem to always smash a few cookies on the edge of the baking field with my big oven mitts, not the case with the extra lip. The only draw bake is that the cookie sheet is rather heavy and with cookies, it may require two hands to use if you lack arm strength.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This quarter sheet is the nicest baking sheet I've ever owned. I've bought just about every brand and size. Baking sheets tend to get rusted and burned quickly and have been something I don't usually spend much money on because of. This sheet is the perfect size for everyday use in my single-person household. The sheet itself is super thick and works for every single thing I need to throw in the oven. I have become more sensible about what I am putting into landfills and with that have invested in silicone baking sheets among other earth-friendly supplies. This pan fits a baking sheet with some overlap. It's great for meat, veggies, or baking. With foil, I would also feel perfectly comfortable broiling with this pan. It washes up very well in the dishwasher and fits nicely in my cabinets. All-Clad products are slowly taking over most areas of my kitchen and are consistently at the top of their class. An all-around perfect sheet for 1-2 people households or small snacks in bigger households.