Customers appreciate the attractive appearance and modern design of this product, noting its suitability with stainless steel appliances. The product is generally considered well-made and functional, keeping butter covered and easy to clean. However, some customers have expressed concerns about the quality, describing it as cheaply made with sharp edges. Opinions on size are mixed, with some finding it perfect for two sticks of butter, while others expected it to be larger and noted variations in butter stick dimensions between US coasts. There are also comments that the lid does not fit tightly and that a separate dish for the butter is missing.