Customers highly praise the appearance and quality of these placemats, describing them as beautiful, well-made, and substantial. The color options are also a frequent highlight, with many appreciating the natural and coffee shades. While most customers find the size to be good, some have noted they are larger than expected or slightly smaller than advertised. Opinions on the material are generally positive, with customers appreciating its rustic look and thickness, though some wish it were machine washable. A few reviewers mentioned shedding and concerns about fraying over time.