I’ve had this less than a month but so far, so good. I can’t speak on longevity of this item but it seems sturdy enough to last quite a while. This was easy to put together for me and I'm not a DIYer, nor am I big and strong. I had to tilt it down or put it on its side to add the topmost shelves, but that really wasn't very difficult. I even did it with the wheels on. These units look nice and hopefully they’re recyclable when they come to the end of their life which hopefully will be only after many years.
I didn't have any issues with damage nor breakage from the delivery process. All the pieces were there, even a few extra plastic clips. I installed the wheels rather than the leveling feet. The shelves seems to measure exactly as the measurements are in this description on Wayfair, according to my humble tape measure. I don't have tons of stuff on the shelves so I don't know if it will truly hold the weight that it says it will. I bought two of these units in black, and again, they look nice. I really wish they sold more shelves for this, and at a decent price. I’d like shorter spaces so I don’t have to pile things on top of one another. I’m not using these in a garage or basement but rather right in my living spaces so the ability to have more and smaller spaces would be ideal. I probably have about a hundred pounds or so on each of these and they move easily with that. I’m sure they will hold quite a bit more but I have no idea if it will really be as sturdy with the labeled weight limit in the description. There doesn’t seem to be any unsturdiness as is and I don’t fear it tipping when I move it but I also don’t push it carelessly. I can scoot it over a few feet with one hand and probably farther if needed. In my small space, shelves on wheels are ideal because I can put them in front of things like closets or windows and move them easily when needed.
The biggest pain, which isn’t a fault, was trying to decide how tall I wanted each shelving space to be. I had to measure my small appliances and count notches to make sure things were even, I didn’t need equidistant spaces. I put the biggest space on the bottom and that’s where I put the heavier stuff, which makes sense to me in case there are ever any tipping issues, which I don’t think there will be. I also bought some S-Hooks to hang stuff on the sides (bags, cords, anything that’s hangable) and that’s working well also.
I prefer these 18" deep shelves over the 14" because that 4” makes a difference for me. I do have a couple of the 14" deep steel shelves too in narrower areas. Honestly, so far, I can't see anything wrong with these two I bought. All the pieces were there. The instructions were clear and were picture instructions. There are too many hard plastic packing pieces that don't seem to be recyclable but it didn't seem to have too different of an amount of pieces than the other two brands of shelving I purchased. The box was a plain brown box with black print and that makes me happy because I’m sure they are are recyclable. Plain brown cardboard box that's absolutely recyclable will do for me, I don’t need fancy advertising. I paid 92 for these and am thinking of getting a couple more if the price goes back down. I’d like to replace the cheaper plastic shelves I purchased that don’t have wheels on them at all.