After searching for a while, reading tons of reviews, I decided to go with the Burlington Fire Pit table. So far, it has been great. I like the design, the fact I can make it a table with the cover it comes with, and the 50,000 BTU for a bit more warmth when the weather changes.
Easy to assemble (I did it myself with some help from my 12 yo), gas tank fits in perfectly underneath. We have used it 3 times, and it has turned on with no problem, enjoyed the warmth and made s'mores.
The cover it comes with (and now Im referring to the black one that covers the unit when we are done with it, for rain and snow) its thin and Im not sure how long it will last. It has rained a lot on that, and the fire pit was dry after. I did get another cover after reading reviews, just in case, and because I need something sturdier for the NE weather.
It does not have the feel of a wood fire pit, of course, but I wanted something I could turn on quickly if I felt like it, without having to look for wood, work on the fire, and turn it off when we are done, without having to wait until the wood burns off. No smoke, no smell of smoke on my hair, clothes, etc, which is a great plus for me.
If I want that, I can still do it with a regular fire pit, and some days I may, but I will be using my gas fire pit WAY more frequently than the wood one.
As for durability, I will have to update my review in a few months....